Home > Managing Consultants > Evaluation of Consulting Staff

Evaluation of Consulting Staff

The cornerstone of consulting excellence is the quality of the consulting staff.  So how do you make the decision on who is high quality and who isn’t?

Two factors come into play:  performance and cultural fit.

Performance is easily measured by utilization, realization, client satisfaction and revenue generation.  If you don’t already objectively target and measure the above, start.  More postings on this later.  A high performer will be at 100% of targets in almost any give 12 month rolling period.

Cultural fit assumes you have a culture to which being a fit is rewarding.  If you don’t place any effort on cultural excellence inside your firm, you should – see my previous post on mission as a foundation to culture.  I’ll write more on cultural excellence in later posts.  In the meantime, use observed teamwork, client sat and general “does this person get along well with others” as a proxy.

Using the above, everyone will fall into one of four categories, listed below by ease of corrective action.

High Performer, Gets the Culture

This is the easy one.  Do what you must to keep these people on the team and pay them plenty of attention.  The majority of your personnel management time should be focused on this group of people.

Low Performer, Doesn’t Get the Culture

Fire them.  They may have room for improvement, but you don’t have time to do it.  After you are done, review your hiring procedures to find out why they even got a job with you in the first place. 

Low Performer, Gets the Culture

This is a little harder.  This person will fit in extremely well with their teammates, do well with clients (at least in terms of personality) and be generally a good fit for all the cultural elements of the firm.  However, period over period, their performance will be below their peer group, their work will be substandard and you’ll find yourself always accepting or making up making up reasons for their poor performance.

Get them on a 90 day plan that specifically addresses the performance shortcomings.  Invest the time to make sure they have a more than fair chance.  The extra effort you invest, if they improve, will be more than paid off in loyalty, a strengthened corporate culture and improved performance.  If they don’t improve, you must fire them.  A consultancy is a meritocracy, not a remedial education program – consistent low performers have no long term role on the team.

High Performer, Doesn’t Get the Culture

This is the hardest category to manage.  Top performance on a consistent basis makes these people very valuable to the firm.  Poor cultural fit makes them very hard to work with.  So, you’ll find them to be top revenue producers, but will often find they work poorly on project teams, care little about the impact of their behaviors on those around them and on occasion will cause client satisfaction issues. 

What to do?  Counsel, counsel and more counsel – this is the group that should consume the second biggest amount of your personnel management time.   During performance management reviews, you’ll have to spend your time consistently coaching them on better behavior and matters of emotional intelligence.  Change will be slow – their cultural fit will only improve to the extent you can show them how it will make their lives easier or increase their personal performance.  Ultimately, this group is like Dennis Rodman – a top performer whose high-maintenance personality only makes them employable as long as the performance stays high.  When the performance slips, they give you no reason to continue their maintenance.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: